Looking for The Best Criminal Defense Attorneys in Dallas? SCHEDULE A CONSULTATION
Texas Self-Defense: Protecting Others When the Stakes Are High

Texas Self-Defense: Protecting Others When the Stakes Are High

Have you ever found yourself in a situation where someone you care about is in danger? Maybe you witnessed a mugging or saw a friend getting attacked. In the heat of the moment, your instincts kick in to protect them. But what happens if you use force to intervene? Can you legally defend someone else in Texas?

The answer is yes, but Texas law has specific guidelines for using force in self-defense, and those guidelines extend to protecting others as well. Here at M|C Criminal Law, a Dallas-based criminal defense firm, we understand the complexities of self-defense laws, especially when the well-being of another person is on the line. In this blog post, we'll break down the legalities of defending others in Texas and explore the critical decisions you might face in such a high-stakes situation.

Texas Law on Defense of a Third Person:

Texas Penal Code Section 9.33 outlines the legal justification for using force to defend another person. This law essentially states that you can use force, even deadly force, to protect someone else if the following conditions are met:

  • Reasonably Believe Unlawful Force is Present: You must have a reasonable belief that the person you are protecting is facing unlawful force or its attempted use. This means you can’t simply intervene in a shoving match or verbal argument. The threat must be serious and involve the potential for significant harm.

  • Same Justification as Self-Defense: Imagine yourself in the situation – under Texas law, you would be justified in using force to protect yourself from the same threat. Put another way, the level of threat against the person you are defending needs to be just as serious as a threat that would warrant your own self-defense.

  • Immediate Intervention Necessary: Your use of force must be immediately necessary to stop the threat. This means there’s no time to call for help or retreat safely. You’re essentially the only line of defense between the other person and imminent harm.

It’s important to remember that “reasonable belief” is a crucial concept here. The law doesn’t expect you to be a mind reader, but your actions should be based upon what a reasonable person would believe in the same situation.

Understanding "Reasonable Belief" in Self-Defense:

So, what exactly constitutes a "reasonable belief" when defending another person? Let's break it down:

  • Objectivity is Key: Your belief about the threat can't be based on personal feelings or biases. It needs to be grounded in the objective facts of the situation.

  • Severity of the Threat: The severity of the threat is paramount. Witnessing a robbery with a weapon would likely justify using force, while intervening in a heated argument probably wouldn't.

Here's an example: Imagine you see someone attacking your friend on the street. The attacker is much larger and is clearly throwing punches. In this scenario, you might reasonably believe your friend faces unlawful deadly force, justifying your use of force to intervene.

However, keep in mind that every situation is unique. What's considered "reasonable" depends entirely on the specific details.

The Importance of De-escalation (when possible):

Before resorting to force, it's always best to try and de-escalate the situation if possible. Here are some strategies to consider:

  • Calling for Help: If there's a chance to call 911 or security without putting yourself or others at further risk, do so.

  • Verbal Intervention: Sometimes, a firm voice and a clear command to stop can be enough to defuse a tense situation.

  • Creating Separation: If possible, try to physically separate the individuals involved, creating space for things to calm down.

Remember, de-escalation is always the preferred course of action when there's a chance it might work.

When You've Used Force to Defend Another Person

The aftermath of using force to defend someone, even if justified, can be a stressful and confusing time. Here's what you should do:

  • Seek Safety: The immediate priority is ensuring your own safety and the safety of the person you protected. If the threat is no longer present,

  • Call 911: Even if you believe you acted in self-defense, it’s crucial to call 911 and explain what happened. Explain the situation calmly and clearly, and cooperate with the responding officers.

  • Do Not Discuss the Incident: It’s tempting to want to explain your actions to everyone involved, but resist the urge. Talking about the incident could be misconstrued and used against you later.  Additionally, if the immediate aftermath you may not explain the situation as clearly or detailed as possible.  Be polite and request to have an attorney present to discuss the event.

  • Call M|C Criminal Law: This is the most important step. You will want to quickly make the decision to speak to the police or not and that is a discussion you have with an seasoned professional.  Our experienced criminal defense attorneys can advise you on your legal rights and navigate the potential complexities of the situation. We can represent you during any interviews with law enforcement and ensure your best interests are protected throughout the process.

Remember: Even if you believe you acted in self-defense, there’s always a chance you may face legal scrutiny. Having a qualified lawyer on your side can make a significant difference in the outcome. 

Don't Face the Stakes of Defending Others Alone

Texas self-defense laws provide a framework for protecting yourself and others in threatening situations. Understanding the legalities can be complex, that is why securing legal representation from a qualified self-defense attorney like M|C Criminal Law is vital. Our team can navigate the legalities, protect your rights, and ensure you receive a fair outcome.

Don't hesitate to contact M|C Criminal Law today for a consultation. We're here to guide you through the complexities of self-defense law in Texas. Stay safe and be informed


* indicates required